What the court ordered
Justice Jonathan Beach has issued remedies against Apple in Epic Games v Apple. On the reporting available, Apple may not stop developers from steering consumers to other ways of buying. Information Age reported on 23 October 2026 that Apple "cannot prevent developers from pointing users toward alternative app stores or payment methods". It also reported that Apple has "until at least March 2027" to let Australians download apps through alternative stores, including direct web downloads, and that alternative in-app payment systems must be supported. Apple says it will seek a stay and appeal, and it disputes the market definition on which liability rests.
The orders follow the August 2025 liability ruling. SBS reported on 12 August 2025 that Justice Beach found Apple had a "substantial degree of market power" from restrictions on in-app payments and on distributing iOS-compatible apps. He found that this substantially lessened competition. The same report said the judgment ran to roughly 2,000 pages.
The case now has a remedy, which is the part that matters to developers and consumers.
The strongest case for the orders
The case for acting is strong. Under the company's rules, developers could not tell users about cheaper options outside the app. The ACCC has described the problem: in-app payment systems "often include commission fees of up to 30 per cent", and developers face limits on communicating with consumers about alternative purchases. A rule that blocks a seller from telling customers where a lower price is available is hard to defend as a security feature. A court that has heard the evidence and found anticompetitive effects is entitled to order it stopped, and delay costs developers money every month.
Why the steering remedy is the defensible core
We support remedies that restore information and choice, and the steering order does that. It does not set Apple's prices, design its products or mandate a particular business model. It removes a restriction on what developers may say and where they may send users. That is close to the proportionate, speech-compatible intervention we argue regulators should prefer.
The wider orders on alternative stores and payments are weaker ground. Reported conditions keep a security backstop: apps outside the App Store must pass an automated scan and be notarised by Apple or a qualified third party. That is the right instinct. Opening distribution can raise real risks of malware and fraud, and a remedy that ignores them trades one consumer harm for another. The open question is whether those safeguards work in practice and whether Apple can charge for the services it still provides. The reporting says Apple cannot charge fees on purchases made through third-party stores. That is a contested line, and the evidence on it should be tested on appeal rather than assumed.
What the appeal will test
MLex commentary on 17 November 2026 says Apple's appeal will test two things: the market definitions and the court's remedial powers. Both are fair targets.
Market definition decides everything in a section 46 case. Apple argues its definition has been rejected by other courts. If the Full Federal Court narrows or reframes the markets, the market power finding, and the orders resting on it, could shrink. Remedial power is the second question. Courts can restrain conduct, but designing a working app-distribution regime, with notarisation, scanning and payment rules, is a regulator's job. Judges set these things up poorly because they cannot monitor compliance, adjust rules when threats change, or consult the whole market.
The case also shows how slow this route is. The liability ruling came in August 2025, and the earliest date reported for the main remedies is March 2027. That is roughly 19 months, and appeals may add more. For a market that changes every product cycle, litigation is a poor primary tool.
What it means for the proposed digital competition regime
The MLex view is that the case shows why Australia needs the regime the government has proposed. That argument has force, but it needs care. Treasury's December 2024 proposal and the ACCC's welcome for it named app marketplaces as a priority concern, with possible obligations on in-app payment requirements and on communicating with consumers about alternatives. The ACCC's final Digital Platform Services Inquiry report, published on 23 June 2025, recommends that the ACCC keep a monitoring function under the proposed regime.
A regime built on narrow, tested obligations would do what the court is now improvising. It would set clear rules on steering and payments, with a regulator that can review them. But the design risks are real. Broad designation powers, vague duties and weak appeal rights would swap one uncertainty for another and could chill product investment. Australia should legislate the specific conduct rules the evidence supports. It should require the ACCC to show consumer harm and to weigh security, and it should provide for merits review.
The takeaway
The steering order is a narrow and defensible remedy. The wider distribution orders will turn on how the appeal handles market definition, security trade-offs and Apple's right to be paid for real services. Whatever the outcome, the case argues for targeted, evidence-led ex ante rules rather than reliance on multi-year litigation. It does not argue for a sweeping regime.