US spectrum 5G policy

The FCC's 482 MHz Satellite-to-Phone Proposal Is Right to Expand Supply, but Carrier Interference Claims Need Measured Evidence

The FCC unanimously proposed up to 482 MHz more spectrum for satellite-to-phone service. The open question is who can use it and what it costs terrestrial 5G.

FCC D2D Spectrum Proposal at a Glance People of Internet Research · US 482 MHz Additional D2D spectrum proposed Added to the SCS framework under t… 5 → 13 SCS-eligible bands Proposed increase in bands for SCS… 25 MHz Mid-band auction proposed 1675-1695 and 2020-2025 MHz, for 5… $40B+ D2D capital since SCS Flowed through the US space econom… peopleofinternet.com
FCC D2D Spectrum Proposal at a Glance People of Internet Research · US 482 MHz Additional D2D spectrum proposed 5 → 13 SCS-eligible bands 25 MHz Mid-band auction proposed $40B+ D2D capital since SCS peopleofinternet.com

Key Takeaways

On 29 October 2026 the Federal Communications Commission voted unanimously to seek comment on a plan to make more spectrum available for direct-to-device (D2D) service, according to Broadband Breakfast. A notice of proposed rulemaking is only a request for comment, and nothing in it licenses anyone to transmit. It is still the most consequential signal yet on how Washington will divide scarce spectrum between satellites and terrestrial 5G.

What the FCC proposed

According to Via Satellite, the notice would raise the number of bands eligible for Supplemental Coverage from Space (SCS) from five to 13 and make an additional 482 MHz available. It also asks whether to eliminate the geographically independent area and lease requirements that currently govern SCS. SCS is the framework the Commission adopted in 2024 to let satellite operators use terrestrial carriers' licensed spectrum, via a lease, to reach ordinary phones.

The same meeting advanced a separate proposal to auction 25 MHz in the 1675–1695 MHz and 2020–2025 MHz bands. Via Satellite reports that this spectrum could carry D2D service, flexible-use terrestrial networks such as 5G, or both. Chairman Brendan Carr said he expected "big interest in this seemingly modest amount of spectrum."

The 1675 MHz piece depends on federal work that is still unfinished. In a 26 February 2026 letter to Carr, NTIA identified 1675–1680 MHz as the first of 500 MHz to be reallocated under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. It found that sharing with typical commercial wireless deployments is feasible, subject to coordination around four protected federal sites. It also said it would study the band further as a D2D candidate. Light Reading reports that Carr said he is awaiting a final NTIA study.

The strongest case for caution

The carriers' objection deserves a fair hearing. Light Reading reports that AT&T, T-Mobile and Verizon warn that running D2D in the 2.5 GHz and 3.45 GHz bands would cripple 5G performance, and they want those bands removed from the proposal. Those are mid-band frequencies where carriers have spent heavily on auctions and network buildout. A satellite transmitting at a phone from orbit covers a very wide footprint, and if the interference modelling is wrong, the harm lands on tens of millions of terrestrial subscribers who never chose a satellite service. Carr acknowledged this, saying there are "important technical questions to answer about whether satellite and terrestrial uses can successfully coexist."

That concern is legitimate. But a warning from incumbents is not a measurement. Incumbent licensees have a commercial interest in keeping rivals out of adjacent spectrum, and the FCC is right to put their claims into a public record where engineers can test them. Asking for comment is the proportionate response. Neither striking the bands in advance nor granting access in advance would be.

Why more supply is the right instinct

The demand is real, and so is the money behind it. The FCC's own 15 July 2026 announcement of a related D2D proceeding says more than $40 billion has flowed through the American space economy for D2D since the SCS framework was adopted. It cites SpaceX's 2025 purchase of 65 MHz of D2D spectrum from EchoStar for $19.6 billion. That capital would not be committed if a market for satellite-to-phone coverage in dead zones did not exist. Scarcity of usable spectrum, not a lack of investor appetite, is what limits the sector.

Expanding the pool serves a pro-innovation, pro-competition goal that regulation can legitimately pursue. Spectrum is the one input that new entrants cannot build or buy on the open market without a regulator's help. Each additional band that is opened to shared use lowers the cost of entry.

The competition question is where the real fight is

Commissioner Anna Gomez framed the issue as market structure. In Light Reading's account she said she worries about "competition and making sure that everyone that wants to have access to spectrum, within reason, can get it." Her instinct to prevent one or two firms from dominating D2D is sound, and the evidence of consolidation is already visible. The FCC's own release also lists AST's $550 million L-band agreement and Amazon's and Rocket Lab's separate deals for Globalstar and Iridium, together nearly $20 billion.

The lease-based SCS model has a built-in tension. Satellite operators reach consumers by partnering with a terrestrial carrier that holds the underlying licence. If the rules keep the geographically independent area requirement and strict lease terms, they preserve incumbent carriers as gatekeepers. Dropping them, as the notice asks, could let satellite firms deal directly with spectrum holders in more places. But it could also hand an advantage to whoever already owns the most spectrum or the biggest constellation. The FCC should resist the temptation to settle that tension by picking a champion.

What a proportionate outcome looks like

Three principles follow from the record so far.

The notice is a request for comment, not a decision, and the final rules will depend on what engineers and competitors put into the record. The FCC has asked the right question: how to open spectrum for satellite service without degrading the terrestrial networks that most Americans use daily. The answer should come from measured interference data, not from whichever industry lobbies loudest.

Sources & Citations

  1. FCC: Chairman Carr proposal on D2D for unlicensed devices (15 July 2026)
  2. NTIA letter identifying 1675-1680 MHz (26 Feb 2026)
  3. Light Reading: FCC seeks feedback on carrier warnings about D2D in 5G bands
  4. Via Satellite: FCC looks to update D2D rules and auction more spectrum
  5. Broadband Breakfast: FCC clears slate of spectrum items