On 28 June 2026, Anojan Sivarasa, a Sri Lankan migrant construction worker, replied in Tamil to a Facebook video. Some viewers found the comment offensive to the Prophet Muhammad. According to Human Rights Watch, he deleted it and posted an apology video. His employer held him, and he was arrested on 1 July. By 9 November, per Sri Lanka's Foreign Ministry, the case had been closed. In between, he was sentenced to five years and then to death.
The happy ending deserves credit. It also shouldn't be mistaken for a fix.
What happened, and who said so
The sequence comes largely from Amnesty International and HRW:
- 27 July: The Criminal Court in Al-Ahsa convicted him under Article 6 of the Anti-Cyber Crime Law. The sentence was five years and a fine of SAR 3 million, about US$800,000. HRW adds confiscation of his device and closure of his Facebook account.
- 17 September: After appeals by both prosecution and defence, the Eastern Region Court of Appeal raised the sentence to death as a hadd punishment.
- 13 October: Sri Lanka's Foreign Ministry says the Supreme Court set the death sentence aside. The deputy foreign minister announced it on 14 October. The Sunday Times of Colombo reports the case went back to the Al-Ahsa court, which referred it to prosecutors on 27 October.
- 9 November: Amnesty's account, relaying the Foreign Ministry, is that the Public Prosecution dropped the case.
One caveat matters. Every post-appeal development comes from the Sri Lankan government. Saudi authorities have not published a ruling that we could find. The Sunday Times says all sentences were set aside and the case was formally closed, with Mr Sivarasa expected home within about two weeks. We have not seen that return confirmed. We have also not seen the Saudi court documents.
The strongest case for the law
The defence of Article 6 is serious and shouldn't be waved away. Governments have a legitimate interest in preventing online incitement and harassment. In a state where religion is part of public law, officials argue that insults to the faith provoke real social harm. Prosecutors can also say they used discretion. The first-instance court imposed the statutory ceiling, but not death, and the system eventually corrected itself.
Why the correction doesn't settle it
According to the Ministry of Communications and Information Technology's English text, Article 6 carries up to five years' imprisonment and a fine of up to SAR 3 million. Those are the penalties Mr Sivarasa received at first instance. The law was issued by Royal Decree No. M/17 on 26 March 2007, per WIPO Lex. It has not been rewritten because of this case. Our reading of Article 6, based on secondary summaries, is that it reaches material affecting public order, religious values and public morals. We could not confirm the exact wording against the statute.
That breadth is the problem. When the offence is defined by "religious values" rather than by a harm that can be identified and proven, outcomes depend on who is judging. Here, the same comment produced a maximum statutory sentence, then a death sentence, then no case at all, within roughly 19 weeks. A rule that can swing from a closed file to execution on the same facts isn't a rule a speaker can plan around.
The death sentence also did not come from Article 6 alone. Amnesty and HRW describe it as a hadd punishment imposed by the appeals court. That means the cybercrime statute served as the hook, while discretionary religious-law sentencing set the ceiling. HRW notes that Saudi Arabia executed at least 356 people in 2025, a national record, and that the Arab Charter on Human Rights, which the Kingdom has ratified, limits capital punishment to the "most serious crimes." A Facebook comment, deleted and apologised for, is not that.
What this means for platforms and workers
The case has two audiences who bear most of the risk.
Migrant workers are the first. They are among the people most likely to be reported by employers, and the least likely to have lawyers or consular backing. Mr Sivarasa was held by his employer for at least 24 hours before police took him. His case turned on unusually active diplomacy from Colombo. Most defendants will not get that. On 5 October, according to HRW, another prisoner attacked him and injured his head and face.
Platforms are the second. Facebook was the venue, but there is no public evidence that Meta played any role in the prosecution, and we make no claim that it did. The practical lesson is narrower. A user can delete a post, apologise, and still face prosecution, because the offence attaches to the act of posting. Deletion tools and apology features don't protect users from this kind of law.
A proportionate alternative
A proportionate regime would do three things:
- Define the offence by a demonstrable harm, such as incitement to violence, rather than by offence to values.
- Treat prompt deletion and apology as mitigating factors, and treat a first-time comment as a matter for a warning or a modest fine.
- Remove death as an available sentence for any speech offence.
None of those requires Saudi Arabia to give up its legitimate security concerns. They require the statute to say what is prohibited and what the penalty ceiling is, so outcomes don't depend on which court a case lands in.
Mr Sivarasa's case is closed, and that is good news. The text that put him on death row is unchanged, and the next defendant may not have a government lobbying for them.