A patient in Nairobi found a CCTV camera in a clinic examination room, pointed at the table where she had undressed for an ultrasound. Kenya's data regulator ordered the clinic to pay her KSh 1.25 million. On 12 November 2026 the High Court set that award aside. The reason was not that the clinic was innocent. The complaint was never heard.
What the court actually decided
In Nutrihealth Solutions Limited v G.W., Civil Appeal No. E481 of 2024, Justice W.F. Andayi of the Milimani Civil Appellate Division found that the Data Commissioner decided the complaint without giving the parties a hearing. By the PPC Land report, the Commissioner's determination rested on "the complaint as received, the response by the Respondent and investigations conducted by the Office." The judge said he "highly doubt[ed]" Parliament meant to give the Commissioner such quasi-judicial authority to be exercised without a hearing. He added that a hearing before the same office that investigates would offend natural justice.
The determination was declared invalid and the complaint was remitted for a fresh hearing, with a mention before the Commissioner on 21 January 2027, according to PPC Land. The enforcement notice of 8 March 2024, which ordered the camera removed along with five other compliance steps, was upheld and remains in force. Liability has not been decided.
The second finding matters more
The narrower holding is routine administrative law. The broader observation is not. Section 65 of the Data Protection Act, 2019 entitles a person harmed by a breach to compensation. As PPC Land reports the judgment, the section is silent on who decides it, and the Act does not expressly assign the Commissioner the job of deciding whether damage was suffered.
The ODPC's practice instead rests on the 2021 Data Protection (Complaints Handling Procedure and Enforcement) Regulations. Regulation 14(3)(e) lets an outcome include an order of compensation, and regulation 14(5) makes decisions enforceable as court orders, per PPC Land's account. The judge called the argument that this goes beyond the parent Act "not without merit," but did not rule on it. He left the regulation's validity to judicial review or a constitutional petition in which the Attorney General is heard.
That restraint is important. This is not a holding that every ODPC compensation order is void. It is a signal from a High Court judge that the foundation is contestable.
The case for the regulator
The strongest defence of the ODPC is practical. Most Kenyans cannot fund High Court litigation over a hidden camera, a leaked phone number or an unsolicited marketing message. A regulator that can order modest compensation quickly gives the statutory right in section 65 real content. In January 2026, allAfrica, syndicating Capital FM, reported that the ODPC had issued 184 compensation orders since the Act was enacted, from 9,061 complaints, alongside 357 determinations, 134 enforcement notices and 20 penalty notices. A right that exists only on paper deters nothing. The Nutrihealth facts, in which footage of the relevant hour was reported as overwritten by the time police forensic examiners looked, show why victims need a fast forum.
Why legality is a pro-innovation concern
The same record explains why the gap should be closed by Parliament and not tolerated. Enforcement that survives only because nobody has challenged it is a weak foundation for a data economy. Firms building health, fintech and e-commerce products in Kenya need to know three things: who can fine them, who can award damages, and what process precedes either.
The Act already makes the penalty regime explicit. PPC Land notes that non-compliance with an enforcement notice is an offence carrying up to KSh 5 million, two years' imprisonment, or both. Those powers are statutory and survived this appeal. Compensation, the power most often used against small businesses, is the one resting on subsidiary legislation. When a power is that exposed, respondents with lawyers will test it, and complainants with awards in hand may find them unenforceable.
A hearing requirement is also not an obstacle to good enforcement. It is what makes enforcement defensible. An award that is overturned two and a half years after the determination, as happened here, serves nobody. The patient waited from March 2024 to November 2026 and starts again, and the clinic spent the same period under an uncertain liability.
What should happen next
First, Parliament should amend section 65, or add a companion provision, to state expressly that the Commissioner may determine and award compensation after a hearing, with an appeal under the Act's existing High Court route. Delegating a damages power through regulations invites exactly this challenge.
Second, the ODPC should publish a hearing procedure now, without waiting for legislation. Notice, a chance to respond to the investigative findings, and reasoned decisions would cure the defect found in this case and protect the rest of its caseload. Separating investigators from the officer who decides would answer the judge's natural-justice concern.
Third, the ODPC should resist treating the ruling as a reason to pause. The enforcement notice power was upheld. Orders to remove cameras, run impact assessments and train staff remain enforceable, and those compliance orders are what change behaviour.
The proportionate reading is neither that the ODPC lost nor that clinics won. A regulator with real power over personal data needs a statutory basis and a fair process. Kenya's courts have now said, politely but clearly, that one of those is missing. The January 2027 rehearing will show whether the ODPC can fix the process itself. Only Parliament can fix the statute.