US child online safety

Hawley-Durbin Arbitration Bill Fixes a Real Gap for Child Victims, but 'Tech Products' Is Too Broad a Net

A bipartisan bill would void forced arbitration for children harmed on platforms like Roblox. The core fix is sound; the breadth and class-action design need work.

Roblox Under Legal Pressure People of Internet Research · US ~200 Federal lawsuits faced Roblox's Q3 2026 shareholder lette… 6+ State settlements reached At least six states on child safet… 138M Daily active users Ages from five to over 25. peopleofinternet.com
Roblox Under Legal Pressure People of Internet Research · US ~200 Federal lawsuits faced 6+ State settlements reached 138M Daily active users peopleofinternet.com

Key Takeaways

What the bill does

On 16 November 2026, Senators Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) and Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) introduced the No Forced Arbitration for Child Sexual Exploitation and Cyber Injuries Act. As CBS News reported, it would let families of people harmed by tech products go to court even if they accepted terms of service requiring private arbitration. It would also allow class actions. It would let survivors choose between public court and confidential arbitration. The bill arrived a day before a Senate Judiciary subcommittee hearing on Roblox that Hawley chaired. Roblox CEO Dave Baszucki was invited but declined to testify.

We have not seen the bill text. It was not retrievable from congress.gov at the time of writing, so this analysis rests on the CBS description and on existing law.

The strongest case for the bill

The argument for intervening is serious. A child cannot meaningfully consent to a click-through contract, and a parent who clicked 'accept' on a gaming account did not knowingly trade away a jury trial over grooming or sexual exploitation. Private arbitration is confidential. That matters because patterns of harm on a platform become visible through public filings, discovery and verdicts. Durbin put it this way: an 'agreement' buried in the terms of service shouldn't limit a child's or family's rights to bring their claim before a judge or jury.

The scale gives the point weight. CBS, citing Roblox's Q3 2026 shareholder letter, reports that the company faces nearly 200 federal lawsuits and has settled with at least six states over child safety. Those federal cases are consolidated as MDL No. 3166 in the Northern District of California, filed 12 December 2025 before Judge Richard Seeborg. A platform with 138 million daily users, per CBS, ranging 'from five to over 25', will see harms at a scale that individual arbitrations hide. Roblox disputes the allegations. It calls the claims 'fundamentally misleading' and points to mandatory age checks for chat and continuous chat monitoring.

Congress has already done this once, narrowly

The bill is less novel than it sounds. In 2022 Congress enacted the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act, Public Law 117-90, approved 3 March 2022. It added Chapter 4 to Title 9 of the U.S. Code. At the election of the person alleging a sexual assault or harassment dispute, a predispute arbitration agreement or joint-action waiver is unenforceable. A court, not an arbitrator, decides whether the chapter applies. The statute already reaches class and collective actions brought by a named representative alleging such conduct.

That precedent is why the core of the new bill is defensible. Extending an established carve-out to minors exploited through online platforms is an incremental step, and the 2022 law passed with broad bipartisan support. It does not reshape contract law. Whether the existing statute already covers these claims is contested in the Roblox litigation. We could not confirm the state of any ruling from primary sources, so we do not characterise one. If the courts end up split, a clarifying amendment is a legitimate use of Congress's time.

Where the design gets risky

The worry is the second half of the title: 'cyber injuries'. The CBS description speaks of harms by 'tech products' generally. If the bill's operative text is that broad, it stops being a child-exploitation measure and becomes a general arbitration ban for any online service. Arbitration is not always a corporate trick. It is faster and cheaper for many small claims. It is also the dispute mechanism that lets smaller platforms offer free services without litigation exposure they cannot insure. A sprawling definition invites legal fights over what counts as a cyber injury, and defendants will litigate that question in every case.

The class-action piece needs the same care. Class treatment makes sense where one design failure injures many people in a common way. Sexual exploitation claims are intensely individual: different perpetrators, different conduct, different damages, and survivors who often do not want to be aggregated or publicly identified. The 2022 statute avoided this by leaving the election with the person alleging the conduct. A bill that lets survivors choose their forum, as CBS describes, is on firmer ground than one that pushes claims toward class mechanisms.

Third, procedure is not prevention. Opening courthouse doors compensates harm after the fact. It does not by itself tell a platform which safeguards work. Age assurance, default privacy settings for minors, and rapid reporting channels are better driven by clear standards and enforcement against actual negligence. Litigation risk from open courts does create incentives, but blunt exposure also pushes firms toward over-removal and heavy-handed age gating that can limit teen speech and access to legitimate communities. Lawmakers should say plainly that they are choosing access to justice and not claiming this is a safety regime.

A proportionate path

Three amendments would keep the bill's aim and trim its risk.

The hearing and the bill reflect a real failure. Families reported harm, and companies reached for contract clauses before accountability. Congress should close that gap, but with a statute drafted as carefully as the 2022 law it builds on.

Sources & Citations

  1. CBS News: Hawley, Durbin introduce new bill ahead of first-ever Roblox hearing
  2. Public Law 117-90 (Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act of 2021)
  3. 9 U.S.C. Chapter 4 (2023 edition), GovInfo
  4. N.D. Cal. docket page: In re Roblox Corp. Child Sexual Exploitation and Assault Litigation, MDL 3166