On 4 November 2026, the Australian government finished defending its under-16 social media ban in the High Court. The hearing ran two days and ended in adjournment. A verdict is expected in the coming months, according to Al Jazeera's report drawing on Reuters and AP. Reddit and the Digital Freedom Project brought the challenge. They argue the law is disproportionate and infringes the implied freedom of political communication.
The strongest case for the ban
The government's case is not frivolous. Its lawyers argued that social media use poses risks to children, including depression, anxiety and suicidal ideation. They called the ban "modest in extent" and said its burden on political expression is "indirect." Parents who feel outgunned by engagement-optimised feeds have a real grievance. Collective action through the law is a reasonable response, because no single family can opt a child out of a social world that has moved online.
The law has also had visible effect. A 16 January 2026 release from the Prime Minister and Communications Minister said more than 4.7 million under-16 accounts had been deactivated, removed or restricted within days of the law taking effect on 10 December 2025. The release itself called the figures preliminary. Al Jazeera reports that government data published in July put the total at about five million closed accounts.
What the court will actually decide
The question before the judges is narrower than whether children benefit from the ban. Per Al Jazeera, they must decide whether the ban's benefits outweigh its restrictions on freedom of political expression. That is a proportionality inquiry, and it turns on fit between the means and the end.
The statute is the Online Safety Amendment (Social Media Minimum Age) Act 2024. It defines an age-restricted user as an Australian child who has not reached 16. The Act sets a civil penalty of 30,000 penalty units for breaching the core obligation. Press reports put the maximum fine at A$49.5 million. The law places the duty on platforms, not on children or parents. It also leaves the start date and the list of covered platforms to ministerial instrument, not to the text of the statute.
This is where the fit problem sits. Reddit told the court it should not be on the list of 10 age-restricted platforms. It called the ban "ill-targeted" and "over broad," according to Al Jazeera. When it filed in December 2025, Reddit described an "illogical patchwork of which platforms are included and which aren't". The listed platforms are Reddit, Facebook, Instagram, Kick, Snapchat, Threads, TikTok, X, YouTube and Twitch.
A platform-by-platform list invites an obvious objection. If the harm is compulsive design and exposure to harmful content, a rule keyed to brand names will catch some low-risk services and miss comparable ones. Reddit is largely a text-based discussion forum. Treating it like a short-video feed is hard to square with a claim that the burden on political communication is carefully tailored.
The costs the government has to own
The burden is not confined to children. Reddit argued the law "has the unfortunate effect of forcing intrusive and potentially insecure verification processes on adults as well as minors." Any rule that depends on age assurance puts identity checks between every user and political speech, not just between children and a feed. The Act does limit this. It restricts platforms from requiring government ID or accredited Digital ID unless they offer alternatives. But verification still shapes who speaks, and how willingly.
The government has also conceded a weakness in its own case. According to Al Jazeera, it accepts that many under-16s can still get around age verification. It said in June that it was considering strengthening the laws and preparing an enforcement lawsuit. That concession cuts two ways. A measure that children can evade is a weaker means of achieving its end. And the obvious response, stricter verification, would deepen the burden on adults. The government cannot easily argue that the ban is both modest and in need of tightening.
A proportionate alternative
There is a better approach than a blanket age gate. Regulators could require safer defaults for minors, such as limits on algorithmic amplification, restrictions on contact from strangers, and friction on late-night use. Those duties target the features that cause harm, apply to any service that offers them, and leave adults' access to political speech alone. Enforcement can then rest on evidence about specific design choices instead of a list of brands.
None of this requires the court to doubt the government's motives. It only needs to find that a restriction this broad has to be justified by showing no less burdensome option would do the job.
What to watch
If the court upholds the ban, expect other governments to cite Australia as a template, with the court's reasoning on proportionality as cover. If it strikes down the listing of Reddit, or the framework itself, the result would push regulators toward harm-based duties. The statute also requires an independent review within two years of the core obligation taking effect, and that review will be a useful moment to test the ban against its own evidence. Whatever the verdict, the government has asked the public to accept a large restriction on the strength of preliminary account counts, not measured outcomes for children's wellbeing. The court should ask for more than that.