On 17 November 2026 the European Commission preliminarily found that Temu breached the Digital Services Act obligation to put in place "reasonable, proportionate and effective measures to mitigate the risk of illegal products". That is the mitigation duty in Article 35. The Commission names three weaknesses: ineffective controls to check product compliance, a weak content moderation system, and an ineffective sanction system for sellers. The findings are preliminary, and no fine has been set.
Why this is a different case from May
The first Temu case was about assessment. In July 2025 the Commission preliminarily found that Temu had not properly assessed the risk of illegal products. It relied on a mystery-shopping exercise that found consumers were "very likely" to meet non-compliant goods such as baby toys and small electronics. That case ended on 28 May 2026 with a €200 million fine, the second DSA penalty after X's €120 million in December 2025. Temu had until 28 August to submit an action plan.
The new case asks a harder question. A platform can write a thorough risk assessment and still run a marketplace where unsafe chargers get through. The Commission is now testing whether the controls work, not whether the documents exist. A report on the finding says the Commission approved Temu's corrective plan on 26 October. The new findings come three weeks after that, so the plan evidently did not close the Commission's concerns.
The strongest case for the Commission
The case for firm enforcement is serious. Marketplace harms are physical, not just informational. A toy with a suffocation hazard or a charger that fails electrical-safety tests injures real people. Marketplaces are also structurally positioned to prevent this. They set seller onboarding rules, control listings, and can ban repeat offenders at near-zero marginal cost. The Commission's complaint about an "ineffective sanction system" is an observation about incentives. If a seller can reappear after a takedown, the platform has no deterrent in place.
Temu is also large. Associated Press reporting on the 2025 case put it at 92 million EU users. At that scale, a small defect rate becomes a large number of unsafe products.
Where proportionality should bite
The pro-innovation objection is not that Temu should escape scrutiny. It is that the standard of "effective" has to be defined before it is enforced, and defined in a way that smaller and non-Chinese platforms can also meet. Three points follow.
- Effectiveness needs a measurable benchmark. The DSA says measures must be reasonable, proportionate and effective. It does not say what residual rate of non-compliant listings is acceptable. No marketplace, in the EU or anywhere else, can promise zero. If the benchmark is "fewer than the Commission would like", compliance becomes unknowable and the risk falls on the platform.
- Product law is the real source of the obligation. Whether a charger is illegal is decided by EU product-safety and chemicals rules, not by the DSA. The DSA works best as a process law that makes platforms act on that substantive law. It works worst when it turns into a general product-liability regime for marketplaces. That would push platforms toward blanket seller exclusion, which hurts small legitimate sellers most.
- Enforcement should hit the goods and the sellers. Customs checks, market-surveillance authorities and seller liability handle unsafe imports directly. Platform fines are an indirect tool. They are justified only to the extent that the platform could have prevented the harm at lower cost than the state.
There is also a consistency problem. The Commission has pursued Temu on an evidence base built from test purchases. That is the right method: specific, checkable, and tied to named product categories. Evidence-led enforcement is what separates a defensible regime from one that looks like trade policy by other means. When fines land on foreign-owned platforms in a trade-tense environment, the Commission should expect its methods to be read as protectionism unless they are published and applied evenly to EU-based marketplaces.
What to watch
Temu will have the chance to examine the Commission's file and respond before any final decision. The statutory ceiling is 6% of global annual turnover. The Next Web put the May fine at about 0.4% of PDD Holdings' revenue, so the May fine sat far below the cap. A second fine for the same platform will test whether the Commission treats repeated failure as an aggravating factor.
The more consequential output may not be the fine but the Commission's reasoning. A final decision that says what an effective sanction system looks like would give every marketplace a concrete compliance target: repeat-offender policies, pre-listing checks for high-risk categories, and seller verification. A decision that stays vague would leave platforms guessing and invite litigation over what "effective" means.
The sound approach is to hold Temu to the law while being specific about the standard. Consumers are owed products that do not injure them. Platforms are owed a rulebook they can read before they are penalised under it.