On Monday, 16 November 2026, a coalition of child-protection groups delivered an open letter to the Union Buildings in Pretoria and to Tuynhuys in Cape Town. It asks President Cyril Ramaphosa to ban social media for under-16s and to take urgent statutory action. The signatories include Smartphone Free Childhood SA, Childline South Africa and the Teddy Bear Foundation. They also want smartphone-free zones in schools, according to allAfrica's report.
The strongest case for the ban
The coalition's argument deserves a fair hearing. Children's services see the harms first-hand, and parents face a collective-action problem. If most of a child's classmates are on a platform, a single family that says no pays a social cost. A statutory age floor takes that burden off individual parents and gives them something to point to. Nica Maree, co-founder of Smartphone Free Childhood SA, argues that South Africa is "not … in completely uncharted waters" and that children "do not have the skills and tools to navigate that landscape." That is a serious position, and it comes from groups that work with children every day.
What the minister actually said
The government's position is narrower than "no action." On 4 September 2026, MP Malebo Patricia Kobe asked Communications Minister Solly Malatsi in written question NW4615 whether he intends to introduce legislation or regulations restricting social media access for under-16s. His reply, recorded by the Parliamentary Monitoring Group, was "No." He said there is "no irrefutable indication that a general social media access ban for persons under 16 years old" actually stops them from being digitally active on those platforms.
The reply is short, so what sits behind it comes from press coverage. Biometric Update reads it as a preference for platform accountability over blanket age restrictions. It notes that Malatsi had urged platforms in July, at the Social Media Summit, to build stronger internal mechanisms for managing harmful content. EWN reported on 9 September that the government will not introduce an under-16 ban anytime soon. It quoted a digital-wellness consultant who said the state may also doubt it could enforce such a ban.
The minister's reasoning has two parts: the evidence for effectiveness is inconclusive, and enforcement is hard. The letter addresses neither.
The enforcement problem is the real problem
A ban is only as good as the mechanism that tells a 15-year-old from a 16-year-old. In practice that means age verification, and any age check for a whole user base has costs. Every adult must prove who they are before speaking online. Platforms must collect identity or biometric data, and that data becomes a target for breaches. South Africa has no universal digital ID that platforms could check against. Minors can borrow an older sibling's or a friend's ID, which is the workaround critics of age-gating most often cite.
The free-speech cost is also real. Young people use social media for civic participation, for support communities, and for news in a country where mobile data is the main route online. A blanket ban removes all of that for 15-year-olds, not just the harmful parts. It also pushes the determined ones toward less moderated corners of the internet, where no platform is accountable to anyone.
The cost of getting it wrong is lopsided. If a ban fails, children stay on the platforms and the state has spent its credibility on an unenforceable rule. If it succeeds only by forcing identity checks on every user, adults pay for it in lost anonymity and privacy.
South Africa already has a children's data framework
The campaigners ask for new statutory action, but a statute already covers part of this. The Protection of Personal Information Act 4 of 2013 treats children's data specially. Section 34 generally prohibits processing a child's personal information, and section 35 lifts that prohibition where processing is "carried out with the prior consent of a competent person." The Information Regulator can also authorise processing in the public interest and attach conditions. These include notice requirements, safeguards on data integrity and confidentiality, and a duty not to encourage children to disclose more than necessary.
That gives regulators a lever without a new age ban. The questions to put to platforms are concrete. How do they obtain parental consent for South African minors? What do they do with the data they collect? Are their default settings safe for children? Pressure on those points targets the harm directly, such as profiling and engagement-maximising design. It does so without requiring identity checks on every adult.
A proportionate path
The minister is right that the evidence for a blanket ban is not there yet, and that enforcement is the hard part. But "no ban" must not become "no action." Three steps are within reach:
- Use the existing law. The Information Regulator should test whether platforms obtain valid competent-person consent for under-18 users under section 35, and publish what it finds.
- Demand safe-by-default design. Platforms should be pushed toward private-by-default accounts for minors, limits on late-night notifications, and parent-linked options. Several of these were suggested in the EWN coverage.
- Set evidence requirements. If the government revisits an age floor, it should first pilot and measure it. It should consider privacy-preserving verification and publish its results, rather than legislate on the strength of foreign headlines.
School-level phone rules, one of the coalition's asks, sit in a different category. They restrict a device in a room the school controls, not a citizen's speech, so they are easier to enforce and far less intrusive. They deserve to be considered separately from the ban.
The coalition has rightly put children's online safety on the Presidency's desk. The task now is to answer the enforcement question with measures that work and that leave the open internet intact for everyone else.