Russia Russia SORM surveillance VPN ban

Russia's 60-Billion-Ruble Filtering Budget Shows Censorship Is Now a Recurring Cost, and VPN Users and Domestic Firms Pay It

Russia's 2027–2029 draft budget puts nearly 60 billion rubles into TSPU traffic filtering while it tightens VPN rules. The money buys control, not security.

Russia's Filtering Build-Out in Numbers People of Internet Research · Russia ~60B ₽ Filtering budget 2027–2029 Three annual subsidies of about 19… 1,213 Russian App Store takedowns, 2025 Of 2,045 government-demanded remov… ~57M Estimated Russian VPN users About 40 percent of the population… 469+ VPNs blocked by Feb 2026 Blocked under the 2017 law, per HR… peopleofinternet.com
Russia's Filtering Build-Out in Number… People of Internet Research · Russia ~60B ₽ Filtering budget 2027–2029 1,213 Russian App Store takedowns, 2025 ~57M Estimated Russian VPN users 469+ VPNs blocked by Feb 2026 peopleofinternet.com

Key Takeaways

Russia's draft federal budget for 2027–2029 would give Roskomnadzor's Main Radio Frequency Center a record sum for traffic filtering. Meduza's 8 October 2026 explainer puts it at nearly 60 billion rubles over three years, paid as an annual subsidy. The per-year lines it cites are 19.87 billion rubles for 2027, 19.84 billion for 2028 and 19.87 billion for 2029. Those sum to about 59.6 billion. Meduza says earlier plans showed roughly 9.87 billion and 9.84 billion for the first two years, and that the new draft "simply puts a 1 in front of each figure." The money upgrades and runs TSPU, the deep-packet-inspection boxes installed on operators' networks.

The case for the state's position

Governments have legitimate reasons to want network-level tools. Phone fraud and cyber-fraud cause real harm. A state is entitled to try to keep its networks resilient. The corporate-VPN notification bill that Meduza describes is attached to an anti-fraud bill, so the stated purpose is consumer protection. Ministers can also argue that a mandated, state-funded system is more accountable than ad hoc blocking by private firms.

The evidence does not support that reading. The system was built for control, and its design shows it.

What the law built

Federal Law No. 90-FZ of 1 May 2019, published in Rossiyskaya Gazeta on 7 May 2019 and in force from 1 November 2019, amended the laws on communications and on information. Article 46 obliges every operator to "install in its communications network technical means of countering threats". Under Article 65¹ the federal regulator supplies that equipment free of charge. The statute never uses the word "filter," yet Meduza reports that the equipment lets Roskomnadzor filter traffic and block services at its own discretion. In October 2023 the regulator's head, Andrey Lipov, said all communications nodes were "100% covered." The new budget therefore pays to maintain and expand a system that already reaches the whole network.

The VPN crackdown is the real target

Meduza lists three measures alongside the budget.

Human Rights Watch's 24 September 2026 report describes the broader pattern. A 2017 law bars VPNs from providing access to state-blocked sites. By February 2026, HRW says, at least 469 VPNs had been blocked under it. In April 2026 the Ministry of Digital Development instructed more than 20 large internet companies to collect information on clients' VPN use and deny access when one is detected. HRW also cites an estimated 57 million VPN users, about 40 percent of the population. That is an ordinary consumer practice, which is why the corporate notification rule matters. Any firm that secures remote work or links offices through a VPN would have to report to the regulator.

Platforms are being pressed into the system

Platform intermediaries carry the other half of the burden. Apple's 2025 App Store Transparency Report lists 2,045 apps removed worldwide after government takedown demands. Russia accounts for 1,213 of them, followed by Vietnam at 335 and China mainland at 196. HRW notes that Apple told it a failure to comply with lawful orders could end its ability to operate the App Store in Russia. On 30 October 2026 the Electronic Frontier Foundation reported that VPN developers say their apps are again being pulled, and called it "an unacceptable crackdown on a vital tool to protect privacy and speech online." The EFF post gives no removal counts or legal basis for the new wave, so treat it as a developer-reported trend.

Why this is poor policy

First, the approach fails on its own terms. HRW describes VPN providers adapting through whole-subnet blocks and Amnezia's roughly one-and-a-half-month recovery in June 2026. This is an arms race, and each round costs more. Meduza's 6 October report says experts attribute the rising bill to higher equipment prices, growing traffic and sanctions that make imported components harder to obtain. A censorship budget therefore grows with data volume, whatever the underlying threat.

Second, the costs fall on innovation. Compliance rules fall on hosting firms, app developers and any business with a VPN. A register of VPN hosts and mandatory notifications push security tooling out of the legal economy. Whitelist shutdowns, in which only state-approved sites stay reachable, damage ordinary commerce, and HRW reports that they have grown since spring 2025.

Third, proportionality is missing. If fraud were the aim, targeted measures would be the answer: sender authentication, telecom-fraud takedowns and bank-side controls. Mass interception of encrypted traffic does not answer a fraud problem. A state seeking to protect citizens would not need to know who uses a VPN.

What to watch

The figures come from a draft submitted to the State Duma and could change. The corporate-VPN and hosting-register provisions are in a bill that has not been enacted. Three things will show whether this moves from plan to practice: whether the subsidy survives the Duma's budget readings, whether the notification bill passes in its present form, and whether Apple and Google keep complying with Roskomnadzor requests. Outside Russia, the lesson is about cost. Fixed deep-packet-inspection infrastructure creates a standing capability, and a standing capability tends to find new uses. Democracies debating VPN restrictions in age-verification laws should note that Moscow's budget shows what such a system costs once built.

Sources & Citations

  1. Meduza: Russia plans to spend nearly 60 billion rubles over three years on traffic filtering (8 Oct 2026)
  2. Meduza: Russia to double spending on internet traffic blocking and filtering (6 Oct 2026)
  3. Federal Law No. 90-FZ of 1 May 2019 (official text, Rossiyskaya Gazeta)
  4. Apple 2025 App Store Transparency Report
  5. Human Rights Watch: Russia crackdown on bypassing online censorship (24 Sep 2026)
  6. EFF: Why VPNs Are Worth Defending (30 Oct 2026)