This week the Delhi High Court issued notice to the Centre and Meta on a petition by LiveLaw challenging Rule 4(4) of the IT Rules, 2021. The bench of Acting Chief Justice Nitin Wasudeo Sambre and Justice Sanjay Sharma gave both sides four weeks to respond and listed the matter for 18 January 2027, according to MediaNama's report. The facts are small, but the question is large: can a private platform's automated filter do the work that Indian law reserves for a reasoned government order?
What LiveLaw says happened
Per MediaNama's account of the petition, Meta restricted three LiveLaw Instagram reels on Supreme Court proceedings in late October. They covered the Election Commission's affidavit on the special intensive revision of electoral rolls, the challenges to that revision, and the hearing on the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Amendment Act, 2026. LiveLaw says the first was restricted within about 15 minutes of posting, "before any human being could have examined a 'legal request'." Two reels were still inaccessible in India when the petition was filed. A fourth reel, on a Delhi Police affidavit, was reportedly taken down on 18 November.
Meta told LiveLaw the content "went against local law". LiveLaw says neither Meta nor the Centre answered its legal notices of 30 October, and that no notice, reasons or blocking order were ever supplied. The petition asks the court to strike down Rule 4(4), quash two MeitY advisories from October, and declare that platforms cannot use automated blocking against news reports without a court order.
The strongest case for Rule 4(4)
The rule has a serious rationale. As MediaNama describes it, Rule 4(4) requires large platforms to use automated tools to identify and restrict content identical to information they have already blocked. Anyone who has watched a child-abuse video or a non-consensual intimate image resurface minutes after removal understands the logic. Victims cannot be asked to file a fresh complaint for every re-upload, and exact-match detection is the least error-prone form of automation. LiveLaw itself says it does not object to automated action against rape or child sexual abuse material.
The February 2026 amendments also moved the rule from a soft duty to a hard one. Khaitan & Co's summary of the amendments records that the earlier text, which asked significant intermediaries to "endeavour to deploy" automated tools, was replaced with a duty to "deploy appropriate technical measures, including automated tools". The same amendments cut the takedown window for court orders and government reasoned intimations from 36 hours to 3 hours. A regulator facing viral harm would call this proportionate.
Why the design still fails
The problem is not automation. It is that the rule's trigger is a platform's own prior decision, and nothing in it requires that decision to have been lawful. If the first block was an error, or a response to a vague government advisory, the filter copies the error at machine speed. The same dynamic is visible in the reported numbers. MediaNama cites SFLC.in's count of about 268 content restrictions across Meta, X, YouTube and Reddit in the first 29 days of October, of which Instagram accounted for 174. Meta's notices to users reportedly cited a "legal request", Section 79(3)(b) of the IT Act, the IT Rules, or "an automated system", and none named an order or an authority.
That is the opposite of the constitutional settlement in Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015). The Supreme Court struck down Section 66A, and it upheld Section 69A because it was, in the Court's words at paragraph 109, "a narrowly drawn provision with several safeguards". Those safeguards include reasons "recorded in writing in such blocking order", a hearing before a committee, and a hearing for the originator where identified. In the same judgment the Court read down the intermediary takedown rule so that it required actual knowledge through a court order or government notification. Section 69A was upheld because of its safeguards, and an automated filter that restricts a reel within minutes has none of them. LiveLaw's petition makes this argument directly: Rule 4(4) bypasses the safeguards that justified Section 69A.
Scholars have raised related concerns about the 2026 amendments as a package. An Oxford Human Rights Hub analysis of September 2026 argues that the amendments strain the settlement reached in Shreya Singhal. Mitakshara Goyal, writing in Bar & Bench in April, describes the amended rules as pushing intermediaries toward quasi-adjudicatory content decisions. Neither piece decides the Rule 4(4) question, but both describe the same drift: private platforms deciding what is unlawful, with the state's legal authority borrowed and no accountability attached.
What a proportionate rule would look like
The fix does not require abandoning automated matching. It requires three constraints that the petition effectively asks the court to infer:
- Tie the filter to lawful originals. Matching should apply only to content blocked under a reasoned order or in a narrow category such as child sexual abuse material, not to anything a platform has ever restricted for any reason.
- Exclude news reporting and court coverage by default. Reports on judicial proceedings carry the highest public-interest value and the highest cost from a false positive.
- Give users notice and a human review path. A restriction should name its legal basis and authority, and a reviewer should be reachable before restoration takes days.
The Additional Solicitor General reportedly suggested the Centre could treat the petition as a representation and pass a reasoned order. LiveLaw's counsel called that "a mere formality". It is also a telling response. It concedes that a reasoned order is the right mechanism for these restrictions, which is the point of the challenge.
What to watch
Counsel did not press for interim relief and instead asked for a shorter date. The next hearing is on 18 January 2027, so reels about court proceedings may stay restricted for weeks. Courts have so far treated platform actions on individual accounts as matters for civil suits, so the more consequential outcome is a ruling on whether Rule 4(4) exceeds the powers delegated by the IT Act. If it does, India's filter mandate loses its legal footing. If it does not, the court should at least require that automated enforcement carry the notice, reasons and review that Shreya Singhal treated as the price of lawful blocking.