On 23 October 2026, Germany's Federal Court of Justice (BGH) announced that its Cartel Senate will hold a first hearing on 26 January 2027 in case KVB 13/26, according to BGH press release 201/2026. The hearing concerns Amazon's interim application against the Bundeskartellamt's decision of 4 February 2026 on Amazon's price control mechanisms. The BGH has made no ruling on the merits. Its release says the court will first examine whether the authority had the power to act under EU law. It names Article 1(6) of the Digital Markets Act (DMA), Article 3(2) of the E-Commerce Directive and § 3(2) of the German Digital Services Act implementation law.
The case for the Bundeskartellamt
The regulator's case deserves a fair statement. Amazon is both the operator of Germany's largest online marketplace and a competitor on it. According to the Bundeskartellamt's 5 February 2026 press release, around 60 per cent of goods sold on amazon.de come from independent third-party sellers. The platform accounts for around 60 per cent of online retail sales in Germany. The authority found that Amazon's mechanisms remove sellers' offers, or hide them from the Buy Box, when prices exceed Amazon's internal thresholds. It also found the rules non-transparent, so a seller cannot know in advance whether a price will trigger a penalty. A platform that polices its own rivals' prices without disclosed criteria is a real competition concern. Sellers can also be pushed below the level that covers their costs.
The decision is narrower than a ban on price monitoring. Amazon may still intervene against prices in a "particularly gross disproportion" to value, which the BGH release describes as usury-like transactions, or against prices that breach other statutory pricing rules. It must explain how the mechanisms work, how often thresholds change and what the consequences are. The authority also ordered disgorgement of economic benefit. Its release puts the first-step amount at around €59 million, the first use of that power since the 2023 reform. This is disgorgement of profit, not a fine, though some law-firm summaries call it a fine.
Why the jurisdictional question is the real story
The BGH's choice to start with EU competence is a signal. Section 19a GWB lets the Bundeskartellamt designate firms of "paramount significance for competition across markets" and prohibit specified conduct. The DMA, a harmonised EU regulation, now regulates gatekeepers at the Union level. Amazon argues that the decision rests on a purely German provision and would fragment the single market, as the MTR Legal summary reports. The Bundeskartellamt's decision also invokes Section 19 GWB and Article 102 TFEU. The Bundeskartellamt's Amazon proceedings page records the order as made under the special provisions for large digital companies, and Amazon's challenge targets that route.
The interim standard matters. The court must decide whether there are "serious doubts" about the order's legality. It need not decide who is right on the merits. Even so, this is the first time Germany's top civil court will address, in a contested case, how national gatekeeper rules sit alongside the DMA. The BGH says more than one hearing is planned.
What proportionate enforcement requires
A pro-innovation reading does not require sympathy for Amazon's opacity. Marketplaces are valuable because they let small sellers reach buyers, and arbitrary delisting damages that value. The Bundeskartellamt's transparency requirements are the least controversial part of the order and are easy to defend.
The weaker point is the line the order draws around what counts as an acceptable intervention. As Jones Day's analysis notes, the authority's press release does not explain when prices would be considered "excessive". Consumers also benefit when a platform stops a seller from posting a price far above what other shops charge, because the Buy Box is partly a consumer-protection device. A rule that confines Amazon to cases of usury-like pricing could leave shoppers paying more. Yet the authority's own account shows that Amazon's thresholds can also catch ordinary commercial pricing. The Wolters Kluwer competition blog reads the mechanisms as covering pricing errors, excessive prices and prices that are uncompetitive against other online shops. These categories raise different questions, and a blanket remedy treats them alike.
The remedy also carries a suspended timetable. Because of the interim application, the BGH says, the implementation periods are suspended until the interim proceeding ends. For now, Amazon does not have to comply. Sellers who were hoping for relief should plan for months of uncertainty, not weeks.
What to watch
There are three outcomes to expect. If the BGH finds serious doubts on EU-law grounds, national Section 19a enforcement against gatekeepers already covered by the DMA could be narrowed, and the Bundeskartellamt would need to route cases through Brussels or Article 102. If the BGH finds no serious doubts, the suspension would likely end and Amazon would have to change its practices, while still appealing on the merits. A third path is a referral to the Court of Justice of the EU. That would add a year or more but would give businesses a clear answer.
The pro-innovation interest is in clarity. Companies that build on platforms, and platforms that invest in Germany, need to know which rulebook applies and who enforces it. Parallel national and EU regimes aimed at the same conduct impose compliance costs without improving outcomes for sellers. Sound enforcement targets documented harms, such as opaque delisting. It states its standards in terms a seller can apply before acting. The BGH's first question is the right one. Whatever it decides, the answer will shape how far Germany's competition authority can go in regulating digital platforms.