On 21 October 2026 the Center for Democracy & Technology (CDT) and the University of Pittsburgh's Communication Technology Research Lab published "Paid to Post: Mapping the Political Influencer Industry". It documents a market in which creators are paid "from a few dollars to upwards of $30,000 per post" to talk about candidates and causes, often with nothing on screen to tell viewers. The gap is real. The right fix is narrow disclosure of who paid whom, not rules that decide what creators may say.
The case for stronger rules
The argument for intervention is strong. Viewers weigh a recommendation differently when they know it was bought. A creator who tells followers a candidate "changed my mind" is trading on trust that sponsored messaging does not earn. The report finds that partnerships are often arranged through intermediaries such as influencer marketing agencies. These can supply creative briefs with talking points, and some run self-service platforms where creators apply for paid political tasks. Depending on the setup, the campaign may not know which influencers the intermediary hired. If neither audiences nor platforms can see the payment, nobody can tell organic enthusiasm from a purchased campaign.
The oversight gap is structural, not accidental. The report says "no single federal agency has ultimate authority over how political influencers conduct their business." The FTC's Endorsement Guides do require that a paid connection be disclosed "clearly and conspicuously," and the agency's own guidance says the same applies to social media. But that guidance sits in the commercial advertising framework, which the report says does not extend to political advertising and speech. The Guides themselves are an FTC publication, and the FTC's own Q&A notes they "don't have the force of law."
The Federal Election Commission is no substitute. Under its rules, the report says, a federal political committee "needs only to publicly report the intermediary they pay." The creators and their individual payments typically never appear in public filings. The FEC's internet-disclaimer rule generally does not reach an ordinary sponsored creator post, though the report says it does cover paid "boosting." A campaign can therefore pay one agency, which pays dozens of creators, and the public record shows a single line item.
What the states have done
Two states have acted. California's SB 678, operative 1 January 2024, requires paid creators to include a disclaimer when posting about a candidate or ballot measure, and requires committees to notify them. Texas's Ethics Commission amended its rules effective 8 August 2024 so that compensated posters of express advocacy must disclose the payment.
California then added enforcement. Governor Gavin Newsom signed AB 1130 on 19 September 2026, and reporting on the law says it lets the Fair Political Practices Commission impose penalties of up to $5,000 or refer suspected violations as potential misdemeanors. The same reporting says the state had required disclosure since 2023 but had no way to punish violations. Complaints over Tom Steyer's gubernatorial campaign, which paid dozens of creators, prompted the bill. The FPPC closed one investigation after finding the campaign had notified the influencers of their obligations. A second remains open.
Why the design matters
A disclosure duty is the most proportionate tool available. It does not restrict what a creator says, and it leaves the creator free to take either side's money. It only requires that the audience be told. That is consistent with free expression: the speech itself stays untouched, and the viewer gets one more fact with which to judge it.
Several design choices keep it that way.
- Target payment, not opinion. AB 1130 is reported to reach only people paid by a campaign committee. Unpaid creators sharing their own views fall outside it. Any other state or federal law should keep that line sharp, because a vague "influence" standard would chill ordinary supporters.
- Put the duty where the information sits. Creators often don't know the ultimate funder, and campaigns often don't know the creators. Requiring committees to notify the intermediaries they hire, and intermediaries to notify creators, is easier to follow than fining individuals with little power to get the facts.
- Match the penalty to the harm. A $5,000 fine can be a heavy burden for a small creator paid a few dollars, and criminal referral raises the stakes further. Safe harbors for good-faith compliance, and notice-and-cure for first offenses, would protect hobbyists while still reaching professional operations.
- Make payment records searchable. The more useful reform may be federal reporting that traces payments through intermediaries to the creator. That corrects the FEC blind spot without any rule about content.
The report itself is cautious. It has no formal recommendations list, but concludes that policy "must hold voters' interests as the guiding principle." It also warns against responses so restrictive that they limit users' political engagement. That is the right instinct. The pressure to over-correct is real, because the 2026 midterm season will produce more stories of undisclosed campaigns.
What to watch
Three questions will show whether this approach works. First, does California's enforcement reach the agencies, or only individual creators? Second, does a platform-level label for paid political content emerge voluntarily, since platforms are the only actors that see both the creator and the post? Third, does Congress write a narrow federal reporting rule, or does the patchwork grow state by state? With only two states regulating, a creator in a third state faces no disclosure duty at all. A patchwork would still burden national campaigns, but it would leave the audience exactly as uninformed as before.
The lesson of "Paid to Post" is that the missing ingredient is information, not restriction. Policymakers should fill that gap with plain, targeted disclosure and leave the creators' speech alone.