France France CNIL GDPR enforcement Big Tech

CNIL's €7 Million Fnac Fine Targets Ignored Refusals, Not Recommendation Engines

France's regulator fined two Fnac Darty companies €7m because their app kept tracking users who tapped 'continue without accepting' — a narrow, defensible enforcement line.

CNIL v. Fnac app tracking People of Internet Research · France €7M Total fine €6m on Fnac Darty Participations e… €10,000 Daily penalty if late Applies per day if consent complia… 1.5M+ French app downloads Downloads in France between March … peopleofinternet.com
CNIL v. Fnac app tracking People of Internet Research · France €7M Total fine €10,000 Daily penalty if late 1.5M+ French app downloads peopleofinternet.com

Key Takeaways

On 22 October 2026, the restricted committee of France's data protection authority, the CNIL, fined Fnac Darty Participations et Services €6 million and Fnac Direct €1 million, €7 million in total. The CNIL announced the sanction on 29 October (deliberation SAN-2026-015). The finding is that the Fnac mobile app placed and read a tracker on users' devices without valid consent. This is not a case about a company that never asked. It is about a company that asked, was told no, and tracked anyway.

What the committee found

The published deliberation on Légifrance records that users could tap "Continuer sans accepter" (continue without accepting) in the app's consent banner. Even so, the companies went on reading and writing data on their devices through an API. According to the CNIL, the tracker sent a Fnac user identifier and product-activity data to a third-party domain. That data was used for personalised recommendations, complementary-product suggestions and training the recommendation algorithm.

The legal question was whether that tracking fell inside the exemptions in Article 82 of the French Data Protection Act. Article 82 transposes Article 5(3) of the ePrivacy Directive 2002/58/EC. It requires consent for storing or accessing information on a user's terminal, except where the access is for transmission or is strictly necessary to deliver a service the user explicitly requested. The committee held that the operations did not fall within those exemptions. They therefore could not run without prior consent. It ordered the companies to show within one month that their new tool collects consent where needed, on pain of €10,000 for each day of delay.

The case began with a complaint from the privacy group noyb. On 14 September 2023 noyb filed complaints in France against the Fnac, SeLoger and MyFitnessPal apps. The CNIL's online audit of the Fnac app took place on 6 March 2024, according to PPC Land's reading of the decision.

The strongest case for the fine

The case for severity is easy to state. Consent is only meaningful if refusal works. A banner whose "no" button changes nothing is theatre, and it corrupts the market for compliant firms, which pay for lower-yield, consent-based advertising and personalisation while rivals quietly do not. Mobile apps are also harder to inspect than websites: users cannot open developer tools, so regulators and complainants are often the only check. Reading the Fnac app's behaviour as a refusal-ignoring design is a reasonable reading of the record.

Why this is the right line, and where it could go wrong

On the facts reported, this enforcement is proportionate for one reason: the violation is objective. A user said no and the app behaved as though they had said yes. Regulators can test for that without making contested judgments about what counts as a reasonable business model. Enforcement of this kind raises compliance without punishing innovation. Firms learn that the consent signal must reach every SDK and API in the stack, not just the visible banner.

Three cautions apply.

Scale and reach

PPC Land reports that the Fnac app was downloaded more than 1.5 million times in France between March 2023 and March 2024, with an average of about 37,400 daily users. That is a real but not enormous user base. The case is not a Big Tech enforcement action, and its significance is precedent rather than size. It extends the CNIL's long-running cookie enforcement from websites to the in-app environment and shows that a complaint from a civil-society group can reach a decision on mobile tracking. For developers, the practical message is to audit what every SDK does after a user declines, not just what the banner shows.

What to watch

The next signals are whether the CNIL accepts the companies' revised consent tool within the one-month deadline, and whether it acts on the other two apps in noyb's September 2023 complaints. If it stays disciplined, focusing on cases where a refusal was demonstrably ignored, French enforcement can protect users without discouraging useful product features.

Sources & Citations

  1. CNIL press release: Fnac Darty €7m fine
  2. CNIL: €7 million fine against Fnac Darty Participations et Services and Fnac Direct (deliberation SAN-2026-015)
  3. EUR-Lex: ePrivacy Directive 2002/58/EC
  4. noyb: How mobile apps illegally share your personal data
  5. PPC Land: CNIL fines Fnac €7m