What the auditor found
In late October 2026, the CRTC published the independent auditor's report on the Online News Act for 2025-26. Secondary reporting on it, which we rely on because the CRTC's own page returned an access error when we tried to read it, says outlets were paid 60 per cent of their first-year share of Google's annual C$100 million contribution before their applications were fully checked (iPhone in Canada). The same report says full Year 1 funding reached C$96.7 million across 445 eligible news businesses as of 30 June 2026. The Year 2 pot rose to C$102.5 million, with recipients slipping to 425.
The auditor also found that "some news businesses had received funding but did not meet these requirements." The report adds that recovery actions have begun, some money has come back, and amounts deemed unrecoverable are being written off. As reported, it does not publish how large those recoveries or write-offs are. Treat the figures here as second-hand until the CRTC report itself can be read.
The strongest case for the regime
Supporters have a serious argument. Canadian newsrooms have shrunk as advertising moved to a few platforms, and Google alone takes roughly half of Canadian digital ad spending, according to one academic quoted by the Reuters Institute. The Online News Act received royal assent on 22 June 2023. Section 11 lets the CRTC exempt a platform that strikes sufficiently fair deals, for up to five years. Section 86 requires an annual independent audit, published within 30 days of the Commission receiving it. On that logic, the audit is the regime working: it caught the problems and recovery followed.
That reading is fair, and the auditor's transparency deserves credit. But a control that detects a design failure after C$60 million has gone out is not the same as a control that prevents it.
Why paying first was predictable
The CRTC's 28 October 2024 decision granted Google a five-year exemption and required it to pay C$100 million to the Canadian Journalism Collective within 60 days. The Collective was then to distribute the funds "equitably to eligible Canadian news organizations." Two things followed from that structure.
First, the money arrived as one lump sum, on a government-set clock. A private distributor holding C$100 million, with hundreds of applicants and a fixed annual cycle, faces pressure to pay quickly and reconcile later. Verification of newsroom-employee eligibility is slow, document-heavy work. Paying in advance was the rational response to that schedule.
Second, eligibility itself is contested. The Reuters Institute reported in October 2025 that IndigiNews was ruled ineligible because its money would have gone to a former parent company, and that The Rover had to incorporate to meet a two-full-time-employee test. A communications scholar also argued the Collective had taken a looser definition than the Act of who qualifies. Rules that ambiguous will produce ineligible payments, however careful the administrator.
What this means for the policy
For a publication that favours proportionate, evidence-based regulation, the audit offers three lessons.
- Administration is part of the cost. A levy-like transfer is judged by what reaches working journalists, not only by its headline size. Money paid to ineligible recipients and then clawed back is a deadweight loss, and unrecoverable write-offs are a permanent one.
- Size-based formulas reward scale. The Collective reserves money for the CBC and Indigenous outlets and shares the rest by newsroom size. Mid-sized outlets such as The Logic received about C$170,000, and its chief executive complained that "the big newsrooms get bigger and the little ones get strangled." A pot that tracks headcount tends to follow existing market structure rather than reader demand.
- Platform-specific payments invite platform-specific behaviour. The Act was built to compel payment for news that appears on platforms. The only agreement in place is Google's, and it has run for two cycles. Whether the model is sustainable or merely an expensive one-off is still untested.
The free-speech angle is real, if less dramatic than critics sometimes claim. A fund that steers money by employee count and by a regulator-approved definition of a "news business" gives a state-supervised process influence over who counts as press. Some of those outlets are also the ones covering the regulator. That does not make the scheme unconstitutional, but it argues for the lightest possible eligibility test.
A narrower fix
None of this requires scrapping the Act. Three changes would address what the audit found without enlarging the regime:
- Stage the payments. Release a verified first tranche, and hold the remainder until documents are checked. The auditor's own findings suggest paying 60% up front was the wrong default.
- Publish the numbers. If recoveries and write-offs are not disclosed, the public cannot judge whether C$96.7 million in Year 1 became C$96.7 million of journalism. The CRTC should require the Collective to report both, by year.
- Shorten the eligibility test. A clear, auditable rule for what counts as a newsroom employee costs less to administer than a contested one. It would also keep the regulator out of editorial questions.
The next auditor's report is due in fall 2027, by which time the Year 2 and Year 3 payments will have shown whether these problems were first-year teething trouble or structural. Canada should use the intervening months to fix the sequencing now, rather than rely on write-offs after the fact.