On 3 November 2026 the European Commission opened a public consultation, running until 9 February 2027, on a possible delegated act under the Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation (ESPR) covering repairability and lifetime. The indicative scope is consumer electronics, light transport such as e-bikes, and small household appliances. The measures under consideration are access to spare parts, repair and maintenance information, software and firmware requirements, easier disassembly and reassembly, and repairability scores or information at the point of sale, according to Lewis Silkin's summary. Adoption is planned for 2027.
The timing matters. The Right to Repair Directive, Directive (EU) 2024/1799, began applying on 31 July 2026. The two instruments do different jobs, and the quality of the 2027 act depends on keeping them distinct.
The strongest case for ambition
The argument for tough rules is serious. Repair markets fail when the manufacturer controls the parts, the diagnostic tools and the firmware. An independent repairer cannot compete if a component is unavailable or a software lock rejects a replacement. Consumers cannot compare repairability if nobody discloses it. A mandatory score turns an invisible product attribute into something firms compete on. If voluntary behaviour had solved the problem, there would be no need for the consultation.
That case is strongest where the failure is about information and access. It is weaker where regulation dictates engineering.
What the Directive already does
Per the Commission's page on the Directive, manufacturers of Annex II products must repair them within a reasonable time and for a reasonable price. They may not use contract terms, hardware or software that impede repair unless there are legitimate and objective factors. Spare parts must be supplied at reasonable prices, repair information must be easy to find, and indicative prices for typical repairs must be published. Repair under the legal guarantee extends that guarantee by a year. An EU repair platform is expected to be operational in January 2028.
The Directive on EUR-Lex is a remedy-side instrument. It operates after a product has failed and applies to goods listed in Annex II, which are goods that already have reparability requirements in EU law. The new ESPR act is a design-side instrument. Product-specific requirements are what populate Annex II, so the delegated act's scope is consequential: product groups it covers can gain a manufacturer repair obligation downstream.
Where the act should be firm
Three measures are low-regret and should proceed.
- Spare-part access on non-discriminatory terms. Independent repairers should be able to buy parts for a defined period at prices that do not make repair uneconomic. This gives the Directive's reasonable-price test measurable content.
- Repair information disclosure. Publishing disassembly and diagnostic information is cheap relative to the benefit, and it supports a competitive repair sector without dictating how products are built.
- Software and firmware neutrality. Parts pairing that blocks a functioning third-party component is an anti-competitive barrier. The Directive already bars hardware and software techniques that impede repair, and the delegated act can specify what that means for connected devices. A narrow exception for safety-critical components is reasonable, but the manufacturer should carry the burden of justifying it.
These measures protect an open market for repair, which fits a pro-innovation position. They remove obstacles and do not pick technologies.
Where caution is warranted
The consultation also floats easier disassembly and reassembly requirements, and a repairability score. Both carry real risks.
Disassembly rules touch industrial design. Small, sealed devices such as wearables trade repairability against water resistance, battery safety, size and weight. A rule written for a kitchen blender does not suit a wearable. If the act sets design requirements, it should use performance-based tests per product group, not one horizontal template, and the impact assessment should show that each requirement changes repair outcomes.
Scoring raises a different problem. A score is useful only if it is hard to game, comparable across products and cheap to verify. Stakeholders in the preparatory process have questioned whether a scoring system belongs in the same act as the other requirements, and how to define "small household appliances". A badly calibrated score would reward paperwork over real repairability, and small manufacturers would bear the compliance load. The Brussels Times reports that the consultation is open to citizens, businesses, NGOs, public authorities and researchers, which is the right setting to test these designs before they harden.
Process safeguards
Two safeguards would improve the outcome.
First, hold to the compliance lead time. Under the ESPR, delegated acts give businesses at least 18 months to comply, according to the Lewis Silkin summary. That floor should not be shortened, particularly for SMEs and for products that need redesign.
Second, avoid overlap. Products already covered by product-specific rules or voluntary agreements are expected to be excluded. Keeping that exclusion avoids stacking duplicative obligations on the same product.
The Right to Repair Coalition's push for repair targets in the upcoming Circular Economy Act deserves similar scrutiny. Targets can help if they track measurable repair outcomes. They backfire if they reward reporting over repair or force premature redesign. Evidence from the Directive's first year should inform any target before it is legislated.
Conclusion
The Commission is asking the right questions, and the best answer is a disciplined one. Mandate the access that makes repair competitive: parts, information and software neutrality. Treat disassembly rules and scoring as hypotheses to be tested product group by product group, not as defaults. The consultation closes on 9 February 2027, and the evidence submitted by repairers, manufacturers and consumer groups will determine whether the 2027 act expands repair markets or only adds compliance cost.